Dayton BR-1 6-1 User Manual

Page 1
Construction Workbook
BR-1 2-W ay Ref erence
Monitor System
Congratulations on your purchase of the BR-1 2-Way Monitor System. The BR-1 was designed by lifelong audio enthusiast and speaker builder Paul Holsopple. Paul has many years experience designing and building high end systems. Paul w as commissioned b y Parts Express to design a rela­tively low cost system that could rival the high end name brands in sound quality. The team at Parts Express then took this design and assembled the components to create a fairly easy to assemble kit that includes de­tailed assembly instructions and in-depth design tutorials so that the builder actually learns as he/she builds. The end result is a kit that can be built in a couple of hours and enjoyed for years and years.
Page 2
Parts Inventory
Carefully unpack the kit, take inv entory of all parts and make sure that nothing was damaged during shipping. Your BR-1 Reference Monitor System should include the following:
Part # Qty Description
300-645 1 Dayton BR-1 Cabinet Pair 295-305 2 Dayton 6-1/2" Woof ers 275-070 2 Dayton 1-1/8" Silk Dome T weeters 999-200 2 Crossover Boards 027-352 2 47uF-100V Non-polarized Capacitors (C3) 027-452 2 Dayton .1uF-400V By-Pass Capacitor (C3) 004-8 2 8 Ohm 10W Non-Inductive Resistors (R1) 027-418 2 Dayton 3.0uF-250V Polypropylene Capacitors (C2) 266-832 2 1.5mH 18 Ga. P erf ect La y er Inductors (L2) 027-427 2 Dayton 6.2-250V Polypropylene Capacitors (C1) 015-4 2 4 Ohm 5W Resistors (R2) 015-6.2 2 6.2 Ohm 5W Resistors (R3) 260-721 2 .4mH 20ga. Air Core Inductors (L1) 999-201 2 Terminal Cups 100-140 1 6' long 16 Ga. Sound King Wire 095-282 24 .205" (16-14) F-Disconnect 50 PCS. 260-316B 2 Acoustic Foam 1-1/2" 24"x18" 081-422 8 #8 x 3/4" Phillips Pan Head (for woofer) 081-435 14 #6 x 3/4" Phillips Pan Head (f or tweeter & cup) 999-202 1 BR-1 Instruction Manual
Objective
The objective when designing this system was to off er Parts Express customers a great sounding, low cost kit that can be quickly and easily assembled while offering a basic lesson in speaker design. Although cost was a factor, the design must offer excellent perf ormance. In short, a Budget
Many of you have a strong interest in building inexpensive loudspeakers, but do not possess the necessary test equipment to design from scratch. The BR-1 is an effort to provide an inexpensiv e kit that gets the most out of the chosen drivers.
Even though cost was a factor in the choice of components and in the final crossover design, the end result is quite satisfying. The design objective was met with flying colors. The overall sound is smooth and detailed, with a wide soundstage that belies their smallish size. The tonal balance is on the w arm side of neutral, which is pleasing with most types of music. Bass also is impressiv e for a 6.5" driver, the f3 being around 43 Hz. Your BR-1s will perform well for living room, family room, or dorm room music listening or in your high end home theatre surround system.
Page 2
Reference
system. Hence the name Da yton BR-1.
Page 3
The Drivers
Included in your kit are two each of the #295-305 6.5" Dayton mid-woofer and the #275-070 Dayton 1-1/8" silk dome tweeter . Both units hav e been a hot bed of discussion on the for this project. The woofer incorporates a treated paper cone, coupled to a rubber surround. The response is generally well behaved, but does exhibit a peak centered around 3.3KHz.
The Dayton 1-1/8" silk dome tweeter is hands down one of the finest tweeters a v ailable in it's price range! The response exhibits some peakiness, and the driver seems to ha v e a ‘wandering’ Fs, b ut the sound is on a par with tweeters that cost far more.
Parts Express Tech Talk board and are good candidates
6.5" On Axis Frequency Response
6.5" Impedance Sweep
The impedance is smooth, but due to the rather large amount of voice coil inductance , rises sharply . Note in the 2KHz area, where this driver will be crossed over , the impedance is 25 ohms . F or this reason, an impedance compen­sation network will be used.
Page 3
Page 4
About Zobels
This simple circuit consists of a single resistor and capacitor. It is commonly referred to as a Zobel network, named for the Bell Laboratories engineer whom invented it. An excellent starting point can be calculated by using this formula.
R = 1.25 x Re C = Le / R squared
Re is measured voice coil DC resistance in ohms. Le is measured voice coil inductance in henries
R is in ohms C is in farads
I measured the individual 295-305 woofer parameters using the LMS measurement system, and the Le was found to be 1.87 millihenries. Using an accurate ohmmeter, the Re was 6.5 ohms . Using the above formula:
R = 1.25 x 6.5 R = 8.125 ohms so C = .00187 / 66 C = .0000283 farads or 28.3 uF
Although these values will give a good result, actual in box impedance measurements indicated an even better compensation can be had with a 47uF capacitor and a 8 ohm resistor.
6.5" Impedance w/ Zobel Network
As can been seen on the graph above, the impedance is no w very flat through the crossov er region. F rom 250 Hz to 10 KHz, the impedance is 7 ohms +/- 0.5 ohm.
Page 4
Page 5
1-1/8" Dome On Axis Frequency Response and Impedance Sweep
The Crossover Network and Description
Here is the BR-1 crossover schematic.
The low pass filter is a four element filter . L2 and C2 form an electrical 2nd order filter and yields a 2nd order acoustic response. The impedance compensation circuit consists of C3 and R1 which eff ectively flattens the woof er’ s induc­tive rise, yielding a smooth impedance curve.
C3 is actually two capacitors, one a 47uf non-polarized electrolytic, with a .10uF Dayton film/foil capacitor wired in parallel. The reason? NP electrolytics are very cost effective , but exhibit high ESR (equivalent series resistance) and also have some inductive components. Using a small value high quality capacitor placed in parallel with the electrolytic will also parallel the undesirable resistance and inductance, thus reducing them greatly. This method is called bypassing.
The high pass filter is comprised of C1 and L1, and is also a electrical 2nd order yet it yields approximately a 3rd order acoustic response. R2 and R3 attenuates the tweeter’ s output 6 dB to match the w oof er’ s le vel.
Page 5
Page 6
Most loudspeakers including the BR-1 use drivers mounted on a flat baffle. One problem encountered here is the fact that the tweeter’s relativ e acoustic center is set ahead of the woofer’s relativ e acoustic center. In gener al, a flush mounted tweeter’s acoustic center is aligned with the front baffle . A typical 6.5” woof er’s relative acoustic center is set about 1-1/2” behind the tweeter . This means that when fed a signal at the crosso ver frequency, the woofer’s output will be delayed 110uS relativ e to the tw eeter. F or successful filter summation, this m ust be dealt with.
The method used to compensate for this delay in the BR-1 is the use of asymmetrical filters. Normally one would use the same crossover topology for both high pass and low pass filters. A 3
rd
order high pass acoustic slope is used with a 2nd order low pass acoustic slope to allow for the time delay. This technique takes advantage of the phase delay differences between the two filter types and results in a flat summation and allows both drivers to be acoustically in-phase with one another at the crossover frequency .
The crossover filters were designed to achie ve a flat o v erall response. The BR-1 measures on axis within +/- 2.0dB from 100 Hz -12 KHz. Flat frequency response is desirable so that all frequencies are reproduced with the same loudness over the loudspeaker’ s bandwidth. In itself , flat frequency response does not ensure a good sounding loudspeaker. But targeting flat on axis perf ormance is the first step in designing a high performance loudspeaker .
Another, arguably more important goal is flat off axis frequency response. Man y times a speaker can measure flat on axis, but the off axis curves suffer from dips in the response. This is due to insufficient driver overlap , usually caused by using too high of a crossover point f or the lo w frequency driver. Good off axis perf ormance will av oid the so-called Venetian blind effect. What is the Venetian blind effect? When the seated listener mo v es horizontally from directly in front of the speaker, the treb le or high frequency response drops off dr amatically. A loudspeaker which exhibits good off axis response can be listened to well away from directly in front of the speakers and excellent performance will still be enjoyed.
On/Off Axis Response of BR-1 System
Note that even 60 degrees off axis, the woofer is producing a reasonably flat response without deep nulls or cancellations throughout the crossover region.
Page 6
Page 7
Individual Driver and Summed System Response
The above graph was produced with the microphone at a distance of 45", on the tw eeter’ s axis . I pref er to use the slightly farther then 1 meter (39.37") distance to be more in the far field, to get a better representation of how the drivers will blend. The response is within the +/- 2.0 dB window to 12KHz. In fact, the response is commendably flat from 300 Hz to 3.5KHz. It can be seen that the acoustic crossover occurs at 2.1KHz. These curves have been smoothed 1/6th octave.
The woofer’ s peak at 3,200 Hz is still present, and it should be noted that a par allel notch filter could be used in the low pass circuit to reduce it’ s effect. One was omitted to keep in the spirit of a low cost design, since this would add three more crossover components per speaker . I found the peak’s audibility to be relatively benign how ev er .
It’s w orth discussing the parallel notch filter because it is a handy circuit that is used to control frequency response peaks. A parallel notch filter consists of a capacitor, an inductor, and a resistor all wired in par allel with each other, then this circuit is placed in series with the driver.
For a 8 ohm woof er with a typical “peak” (about 5 dB), use the f ollowing f ormula for a starting reference. C = 1/ (33 * freq of peak)
L = .025 / (freq of peak squared * C) With the 295-305 woofer , mounted on the BR-1 baffle , the peak is centered at 3,200 Hz. So … C = 1 / (33 * 3200)
C = .0000094 farads or 9.4 uF L = .025 / (10240000 * .0000094)
L = .000259 henries or .259 mH To find the value of R, you first must find the Q of the peak. Do this b y finding the –3dB points on both sides of the peak.
For the 295-305, these –3dB points are 2,500 Hz and 3,700 Hz. Now use this f ormula to calculate the peak’s Q. Q = freq of peak / (Fh – Fl)
Q = 3200 / (3700- 2500) Q = 2.67
We can now calculate the resistor value by: R = Q / square root of C/L
R = 2.67 / square root of .0000094 / .000259 R = 14.05 ohms
Page 7
Page 8
So the values for our proposed parallel notch filter is a 9.4uF capacitor , .26mH inductor , and a 14 ohm resistor. Unlike the impedance compensation filter discussed earlier, this filter is harder to gener ate from just design formulas. It is best to use some means of measurement to validate the result. Please note that adding this notch filter to the existing BR-1 crossover will change the filter roll off and will necessitate a low pass filter redesign.
Reverse Tweeter Polarity
Reversing tweeter polarity is a quick check performed with even order filters to test the overall phase relationship that exists between the tweeter and woof er. The goal is to achieve a fairly deep , symmetrical null at the crossov er fre­quency when the tweeter polarity is reversed. If one is witnessed when the tweeter polarity is reversed, then it can be assumed that a good phase relationship exists when the tweeter is connected with normal polarity .
System Impedance and Phase
Page 8
Page 9
The system impedance and electrical phase is quite smooth, with a nominal 8 ohm impedance. This loudspeak er will be an easy load to drive for most any amplifier. Ho w ever due to the 82.5 dB sensitivity, a minimum of 75 watts per channel is recommended.
The center to center driver spacing is 5.75", with the tweeter being offset 1" in a mirror image pair . The tweeter is flush mounted to the baffle, while the woofer is recessed only to the top of the basket. This was done due to the 5/8" thickness of the enclosure material.
The Cabinet
The Dayton BR-1 cabinet uses 5/8" thick MDF and has an net internal volume of .52 cubic feet. It utilizes a EBS (ex­tended bass shelf) alignment and is tuned to 38 Hz with a rear mounted port. This tuning results in a f3 of 43 Hz. The box dimensions are 8-5/8" wide, 14-1/4" high with a depth of 11", giving it a small footprint suitable for stand mounting. It is recommended to place the tweeter at, or slightly below ear height of a seated listener.
The center to center driver spacing is 5.75", which is an important consideration. Whene ver you have two drivers combining output, as is encountered around the crossover frequency there will be some interf erence patterns. This interference will create dips and peaks to the frequency response. The greater the distance between the two driv ers, the more intense this undesirable interaction.
The generally accepted maximum center to center distance between the two drivers is equal to one wavelength (13,560) at the proposed crossover frequency .
Max center to center distance = 13560 / crossover frequency So in the case of the BR-1: Max CTC = 13560 / 2100 or 6.45” Since the tweeter to woofer distance is 5.75”, the BR-1 is well within the one wavelength tolerance and will provide a
uniform radiation pattern.
Page 9
Page 10
BR-1 Assembly Instructions
1) Installation T ools Needed
Phillips Screwdriver Wire Cutter / Stripper
Hot glue/gun or RTV Sealant Small pliers
Soldering iron Crimp tool
Silver or Electronic grade solder Utility knife
Crossover Assembly Note
Warning!! The correct assemb ly and wiring of the crossovers is critical to the proper operation of this speaker system. In a worst case situation, an improperly wired network can damage your receiver or amplifier! Please double and triple check all values and wiring.
Assembling the Crossovers
1. Install all components on the boards in their proper location. When installing R1, position it so that air can circulate around its body . Before mounting (C3) to the p.c. board, it needs to be “b ypassed”. C3 is actually two capacitors, one 47mfd. electrolytic bypassed with a .10mfd Dayton poly film/foil. This w as done to improve the acoustics of the electrolytic capacitor . To bypass the capacitor , simply parallel the tw o capacitors together and wrap the smaller “poly” cap leads around the larger electrolytic cap leads and solder. Trim excess “poly” cap leads and use the electrolytic leads to mount the “bypassed cap” to the p.c. board.
2. When positioning components try to keep lead lengths to a minimum. Note: The (L1).40mH inductor should be mounted on its side to minimize the interaction between the two coils on the board. You can trim the length of the leads on the (L1) inductor without effecting its’ value. Using a utility knife, scrape off the enamel coating on the trimmed lead ends so it will accept solder.
Page 10
Page 11
3. To help reduce the risk of components rattling on the p.c. board, (especially the inductors) use RTV sealant or hot glue to mount the components to the p.c. board. We recommend using hot glue due to its faster setup time. If you use RTV sealant, you may need to let it setup over night, before proceeding with the assembly.
4. Solder all component connections on the p.c. board using silver or electronics grade (60/40) solder . At this time, you should also solder the riveted .205 terminal connections. A properly soldered connection appears shiny and smooth. We recommend using a soldering iron with a wattage rating between 20­30watts. Using wire cutters, trim off all excess component leads.
5. Cut the supplied wire into 6 pieces approximately 12" long. Strip the insulation on all wires back about 3/8"-1/2".
6. Using a crimp tool, crimp the .205 terminals on the wire leads. To ensure a tight connection, gently squeeze the push on terminals with a small pair of pliers. Note: If you prefer, you can solder the wires directly to the p.c. board and drivers instead of using the connectors.
Page 11
Page 12
7. The locations where the input and driver output wires connect are clearly marked on the p.c. board. While observing proper polarity attach all input and driver wires to their respective mounting termi­nals. Example: To attach the input wire, take the positive (+) input wire and connect it to the “IN+” terminal. Next, take the negative (-) input wire and connect it to the “In-” terminal. Repeat this step for the woofer, tweeter and other crossover. Again, it is very important to observe the proper polarity!
8. At this point, it is a good idea to label each wire to ensure proper hook-up. Masking tape and a marker will work fine.
3) Cabinet Assembly Instructions A. Installing the Crossovers
To mount the crossovers we recommend using hot glue due to its faster setup time. If you use RTV sealant, you may need to let it setup ov er night, bef ore proceeding with the assemb l y. Y ou could also use screws, but they can be a little difficult to install and you run the risk of driving the screw through the finished side of the cabinet. No crossover mounting screws included.
1. Position the crossov er board on the inside bottom of the cabinet against the bac k wall with the wiring facing outward.
Page 9
2. Glue the crossover in place.
Page 12
Page 13
3. Pull the “labeled” input wire through the terminal cup hole and while observing proper polarity connect the wire to the terminal cup. The positiv e (+) input wire should be connected to the “red” binding post.
4. Orient the terminal cup with the binding posts toward the bottom and install using the small #6 screws and a phillips screwdriver .
5. Repeat these steps for the other speaker cabinet.
B. Install Acoustic Damping Foam
We’ve included tw o (2) sheets of acoustic f oam, one sheet for each speak er . Acoustic damping foam absorbs internal standing waves inside the cabinet and prevents reflections to the woofer
cone. You can install the foam using hot glue, R TV sealant or spra y adhesiv e (3M Super77) if a v ailab le. A simply way to cut the foam is to leave the two sheets “nested” together while cutting. Place the foam on a flat
surface and cut the foam with a straight edge and a utility knife. Make medium depth cuts with several strokes. Do not try to cut through the entire depth of foam with one cut.
Page 13
Page 14
1. The foam must be cut to fit internally on the right/left side walls, rear , top and bottom panels . Do not apply it to the front baffle. Cut the foam to the dimensions shown in Fig. 1
FIGURE 1: Foam Cutting
2. Install the foam on the back of the cabinet first and trim around the port tube. Mak e sure it does not obstruct the airflow to the port tube, as this will alter the tuning of the box.
3. Next install both sides and then top and bottom. The bottom piece of f oam will simply la y on top of the crosso v er .
4. Position the “labeled” woofer and tweeter lead wires through the f oam and run to their respective driver openings.
Page 14
Page 15
C. Installing Drivers
Put sealing caulk around the woofers prior to mounting. When applying caulk it is a good idea to first roll the caulk between your fingers to “thin out” the caulk bead. The tweeter is supplied with a gasket so it does not need sealing caulk. Putting sealing caulk on the tweeters mounting flange may not allow the faceplate to mount flush with the baffle.
1. Attach each wire to the appropriate driver terminals while observing proper polarity (positive to positive, negative to negative). The tweeter has a red paint dot on the positiv e terminal. If y ou decide to solder, be careful not to apply too much heat to the driver terminals especially the tweeters.
2. Install the drivers using the #8 (large) screws for the woofers and the #6 (small) screws for the tweeters. Be careful not to over tighten the screws and strip the wood.
Page 15
Page 16
Speaker Placement
Many loudspeakers are designed without regard to baffle step loss. If a woofer has a midband sensitivity of 88 dB for example, and is mounted on a large infinite baffle (like your living room wall), it will maintain the 88 db sensitivity right down to it’s r ated f3. All frequencies, even the large lo w frequency wa v elengths are supported by the large wall.
But speakers are usually mounted in boxes with varying degrees of baffle width. At a given frequency determined by the baffle dimensions, the lower frequency wa v elengths start to ‘wrap’ behind the baffle . This is called a 2 pi to 4 pi transition and will result in a 6 dB loss in an anechoic chamber.
This is a complicated subject which I only want to touch upon here, but suffice it to say that a typical two way speaker in a normal listening room will exhibit more like a 3 to 4 dB loss in the bass region. If left unchecked, most speakers will sound too thin with too much midrange output.
The BR-1 was designed with 4 dB of baffle step compensation which results in surprising bass output for a 6.5” diameter woofer . The midband is rolled off to match the woof er’ s natural in-room response to achie ve the e xcellent bass performance. The trade off is a loss of some midband sensitivity, with an overall sensitivity of about 83 dB.
In most rooms, you will find the BR-1 to sound best placed approximately 3 feet from the rear wall and mounted on appropriate speaker stands. Ideally you want to place the speakers so they are at least 3-4 ft from side walls if possible
Special comments from the designer
"I was pleasantly surprised when I fired up these loudspeakers to give them a first listen. I have lived with the design for a few months now and my opinion remains unchanged. I sincerely believe the Dayton BR-1 gives serious competition to commercial loudspeakers costing two to three times its modest price. Could they be better? Sure they could. For someone interested in ‘tweeking’, I would suggest using thicker MDF for the cabinet and brace it adequately. It might be beneficial to replace the 47uF NP in the lowpass with a notch filter might be worth exploring too. Upgrading the R2 and R3 resistors to a Axon, Mills or equila v ent type is a possibility also as I suspect a thin layer of “grunge” will be removed. All in all, I consider the ‘stock’ BR-1 to be an outstanding value and tough to beat as-is." -Paul Holsopple , designer
polypropylene
type as discussed previously in the “Crossover Network” section, a
electrolytic
capacitor
Dayton Loudspeaker Co ., PO Bo x 52, Springboro, Ohio 45066-1158
© October 2001 Dayton Loudspeaker Co.
Loading...