Icom IC-91A test in QST magazine (in English)

ACOM 1010: From (K7)C to Shining (WRT)C
The ACOM 1010 amplifier was an important part of both the K7C DXpedition to Kure Atoll (www.cordell.org/ KURE/) in September and October 2005 and my recently completed WRTC 2006 operation in Brazil (www.wrtc2006. com) as PW5Q with Chris Hurlbut, KL9A. In both cases, the amplifier gave a very good account of itself and proved to be reliable and tolerant. Even though operated in condi­tions stressful to the amplifiers (hot and sandy on Kure) and to the operators (quick setup and new antennas for WRTC) there were no failures.
The ACOM packs a lot of punch in a reasonably sized package. For DXpedition travel, the amplifiers fit in a single shipping case and could be easily transported. The amp meets the size and weight requirements for checked bag gage, even with a shipping case. The 700 W output is only half an S-unit down from a full gallon. This power level proved to be perfectly sufficient for controlling pileups from Kure and starting pileups from Brazil. Over the 12 days of nearly continuous operating from broiling tents on Kure, the amps put out full power at all times.
Tuning the ACOM is greatly assisted by the tering” indicators (TRI feature) and the LED forward/reflect ed power output displays. At WRTC, quick band changing was very important. After we marked the presets on the front panel, it was a simple matter to switch and touch up the ful of times we transmitted on the wrong antenna or did some other dumb thing, the protective circuitry prevented any damage to the amp, taking it off-line and reactivating it a few seconds later.
LOAD control in a few seconds. The hand-
LOAD “cen-
TUNE and LOAD
-
-
JAN-ERIC REHM, SM3CER
Figure A — Chris, KL9A, operating at PW5Q with the compact ACOM 1010 amp located between the run (left) and multiplier (right) stations. Aluminum foil on the shelf provided a temporary RF ground for the amp and filters.
Anyone who has set up a portable or temporary station knows that compromise antennas are often required or the circumstances of installation may cause uncomfortably high SWR at times. The ACOM’s ability to tune up and operate with a significant amount of reflected power (up to 250 W) was important at both K7C and PW5Q. We did not have to spend valuable time trying to move an antenna’s low SWR point — we just operated!
While at home I’m an enthusiastic low-power or QRP operator, on contest or DXing expeditions it’s important to put out a strong signal to be heard clearly. The ACOM 1010 allows you to accomplish just that without breaking the bank or your suitcase arm. — Ward Silver, NØAX
as well as a simplified schematic diagram. Ac­cording to the manual, detailed schematics are available from ACOM upon request.
The manual offers quite a few warnings and cautions, and they’re well worth reading to avoid hurting the amplifier or yourself. The only thing I found a little surprising is in the Tube Replacement section. The manual notes that tube replacement is a “complex and potentially dangerous operation that in volves adjustment of the plate idling current. This should not be attempted by the user.”
Parting Thoughts
The ACOM 1010 performed very well
in my home station. The 1010 seems to loaf along at its rated 700 W on SSB/CW and 500 W on RTTY. I’d rate the fan noise as average. Although it isn’t bothersome, it is more noticeable than other ACOM ampli fiers I’ve used.
At first I was a bit skeptical of using rows of LEDs rather than analog meters for tuning and operation. With the 1010 tuned up according to the procedures outlined
­in the manual, I used the service mode to check grid current and plate current. The parameters were always within the normal ranges outlined in the manual, so after a while I realized that I should just oper
ate and rely on the LEDs and protection circuitry to let me know if anything runs amok. When one of the yellow LEDs on
TRI
indicator starts to flicker, it’s time
the
-
to touch up the
LOAD
control or readjust the
antenna tuner.
Of course the 1010 really shines away
from home. QST Contributing Editor Ward
Ø
Silver, N
AX, describes his experiences in the sidebar “ACOM 1010: From (K7)C to Shining (WRT)C.”
US Distributor: ACOM International, 4 Marc Rd, Medway, MA 02053, tel 508­533-7665; fax 508-533-7707; www.hfpower.
com
-
.
ICOM IC-91A Dual Band Handheld Transceiver
Reviewed by Dan Henderson, N1ND ARRL Regulatory Information Specialist
Small enough to fit in your coat pocket, the IC-91 comes in two flavors. The model reviewed is the IC-91A, a traditional analog dual band handheld FM transceiver with 5 W of power on transmit, a wideband receiver and a host of other features. ICOM also offers the IC-91AD, which incorporates D-STAR digital voice and data features. An IC-91A can be upgraded to a D-STAR
capable ’AD version with the optional UT-121 digital unit. See the June 2005 Prod uct Review column for more information on the D-STAR system.
3
W. Silver, “D-STAR Digital Voice and Data — An
Overview,” Product Review, QST, Jun 2005, pp 67-69. This column also includes testing of the UT-118 digital voice module with an ICOM 2 meter handheld. QST Product Reviews are available on the Web at www.arrl.org/ members-only/prodrev/.
3
Charge it Up
-
Like most modern handhelds, the IC­91A uses a compact, high capacity lithium­ion battery pack. A full charge for the
7.4 V, 1300 mAh battery pack takes about 6 hours with the included BC-167A/D wall charger. If you want something quicker, try the optional BC-139 drop-in charger for a full charge in about 2.5 hours. The battery also charges whenever the radio is connected to a 10 to 16 V dc source, and ICOM offers
From December 2006 © ARRL
several optional cigarette lighter adapters
100 800
Snd
245
Audio Output (mW)
250
50
T-R
194
Tx-Rx Turnaround Time (ms)
70 cm
2 M
Key:
† Off Scale
60 110
Img
Image Rejection (dB)
60
110
IF
40
70
I
3
Rx
I
3
Rx
ChRej
50
90
59
Adjacent Channel Rejection (dB)
0.25
0.12
55@20 kHz
73@10 MHz
101
95
0.1
SINAD
Receiver Sensitivity (12 dB SINAD, µV)
60
90
Receiver 3rd-Order Dynamic Range (dB)
Receiver 3rd-Order Dynamic Range (dB)
IF Rejection (dB)
0.14
65@10 MHz
56@20 kHz
59
119
94
194
pr014
245
and dc power supply cables.
The IC-91A operates at 5 W on high power and 0.5 W on low power and incorpo rates several features to conserve battery life. Radio specs call for approximately 5 hours of battery life during normal analog opera tion on VHF and 4.5 hours on UHF. Subtract about half an hour for the D-STAR version. Those figures are based on 10% high power transmit, 10% receive and 80% standby and will vary with actual operating habits.
The N1ND Reality Test
As noted in previous reviews, my very first “reality test” for a new radio is “how quickly can I get on the air with it and have some fun?” Options and features are nice, but the bottom line for any radio is the ease with which you can use it to communicate.
The IC-91A has the usual assortment of function keys that allow you to program and operate the radio. There’s a dual function knob on top of the unit and PTT and squelch buttons on the left side. Even for basic op eration you will want to spend some time familiarizing yourself with the most com monly used buttons and combinations.
After spending a couple of minutes reviewing the manual, I powered up the radio and set out to access a local repeater. First, I selected 144 MHz as my active VFO by pushing the
MAIN button
located directly beneath the
PWR button until the main
display showed the desired band. Then I used the larg er dial on top of the radio, turning it until the desired frequency was displayed. A quick adjustment of the
VOL control (a real
knob that turns instead of up and down push buttons) and I was ready to give the IC­91A what my
From December 2006 © ARRL
-
Elmer jokingly referred to as “the smoke test.”
I keyed the mike, gave my call sign and
-
waited for a reply. As you would hope, I got a quick response and enjoyed a brief chat with a friend who gave the audio
-
good marks. After the initial operation on 2 meters, I tried 70 cm with similar results. I was pleased with the
received audio of the radio. The quality of the audio was solid — very acceptable for a small speaker built into a handheld.
I was struck by how comfortable the IC-91A felt to operate. Some of the hand helds on the market have an almost too-
-
delicate feel, almost like razor-thin cell phones. Others really seem bulky in my hand, similar to the handhelds of decades ago. This radio fit nicely into my hand without an awkward feeling. With the belt clip attached, its light weight didn’t leave me needing to hitch up my pants frequently.
The IC-91A passed the initial test with flying colors and it was time to move on to
-
examining the more detailed operations of the radio.
-
Digging Deeper
Most modern handhelds in a particular category offer nearly identical “bells and whistles.” That said, the ease of selecting and using the particular features important to the user becomes a key component in choosing the right radio.
One thing I look for is the ease with which I can navigate not only the radio, but also the instruction manual. ICOM does an excellent job of presenting the information in its 124 page manual, along with clear illus trations and good step-by-step instructions. The only addition I would make is an index. A PDF version of the manual is available for free download from www.icomamerica. com and is worth a look to understand all that this radio offers.
ICOM has included a useful and intui­tive on-screen programming system for ac cessing the special features in the IC-91A. It takes more effort to explain the process than it does to actually select and set up the features from the
MENU screen.
DTMF and tone squelch (CTCSS/ DTCS), once considered an option in VHF/ UHF FM transceivers, are now the norm. More and more repeaters require a tone for access to reduce interference and to allow frequency coordinators to accommodate more repeaters in an already tightly packed spectrum. The IC-91A makes programming these subaudible tones easy using the on­screen
MENU function.
You needn’t worry about having enough channels for memory storage, as you have some 1300 available. Memory channels
-
-
Bottom Line
The ICOM IC-91A handheld transceiver packs good perfor mance, ease of operation, wide receive coverage and optional digital voice in a convenient package.
-
Loading...
+ 1 hidden pages