Page 1
PopPhoto
> BUYER’S GUIDE
2004
PRINTERS
> THE BUYERS: PHOTOGRAPHERS AT ALL LEVELS CAN NOW AFFORD TOP
PRINT QUALITY AND MAJOR-LEAGUE FEATURES
ight now, the big picture in
inkjet photo printers is that the
three leading brands have
achieved a comparable—and
R
output quality.
Previously, Epson had the edge, but
recent entries from Canon and HewlettPackard have leveled the playing field so
that now, all high-end (and many less
expensive) models turn out beautiful
continuous-tone prints. And aside from
subtle differences in hue, sharpness, and
saturation, color prints from a top Epson,
Canon, and HP look very similar.
On the other hand, there are significant differences in terms of speed, paper
handling, available media variety, and
print longevity. The premium Canon
machines use six colors with individual
ink tanks, which means less waste. Epson’s
top pigment printer, the Stylus Photo
2200, packs seven colors. Recently, HP
raised the bar with an eight-color system
in the Photosmart 7960. The HP 7960
and Epson 2200 also employ special inks
for better black-and-white reproduction,
something Canon needs to work on.
Meanwhile, Canon printers are still the
fastest, but Epson gives you the widest
choice of papers. Epsons come in two
flavors: those using higher-gamut, dyebased inks, and those with longer-lived,
pigment-based ones. But understand that
the life expectancy of any inkjet print
depends not just on the ink, but on many
other factors, including whether the print
HOT
NOT
extremely impressive—level of
Photo-quality inkjets are so
good and cheap that everyone
can afford one.
Digital photofinishing is giving
the do-it-yourselfers a run for
their money.
is mounted behind glass or exposed to
contaminants in the air.
Your buying decision may hinge on
other features, such as borderless prints,
roll-paper handling, and the ability to
print onto the surface of a CD or DVD.
You’ll also find pricey large-format inkjet
models, as well as inexpensive combo
units that double as scanners and copiers.
Of course, inkjets aren’t the only
photo-quality game in town. Olympus,
Kodak, Mitsubishi, and Sony make lettersized dye-sublimation printers that use
resin-coated papers closer in look and feel
to conventional photo paper and more
resistant to scratching and moisture than
most inkjet prints. (In fact, many snapshot-size printers are dye-subs.)
These fast printers, which use red,
green, and blue dye ribbons, plus an overcoat, let you apply a choice of texture
finishes without changing papers. Under
a loupe, you’ll notice that dye-sub prints
are smooth (no inkjet dots), the result of
the dye being vaporized and absorbed
(“sublimated”) into the paper rather than
lying on the surface. The downside? Dyesubs typically don’t produce sharp text in
small font sizes.
Many printers (both inkjet and dye-sub)
have built-in media-card slots, and most
can print directly from a digital camera.
For best results, stick with the same
brand of printer and camera, or make sure
they use the same print-matching language, which embeds the camera’s unique
imaging profile within each picture file.
Some manufacturers support Epson’s
PRINT Image Matching (P .I.M.) II; others
use Exif (Exchangeable Image Format
File) 2.2. A new one called PictBridge
debuted this year, which also allows printers and cameras from different companies
to work together. —Jonathan Barkey
> BILLBOARDS MADE EA SY
Most of us are thrilled to make 13x19inch prints. But what if even that big
isn’t big enough? Enter the Epson
Stylus Pro 7600, which produces
monster-size, borderless blowups (up
to 2x100 feet!) on a variety of papers,
with a life expectancy of about a
century. The 7600 provides superb
prints with its seven-color UltraChrome pigmented inkset. Although
its color range is much better than
that of earlier models, the 7600 also
comes in a
dye-ink version
(print-display
life up to 26
years) with an
expanded color
gamut and better black density . The 7600
costs (only)
$3,000 street.
> KINKO’S—WA TCH OUT!
Tired of desktop clutter? New all-inones from Epson and Hewlett-Packard
squeeze a photo-quality inkjet printer ,
color scanner/copier ,and fax into a
single compact package. The Epson
Stylus CX5200 boasts fast printing,
48-bit, 1200x2400-dpi, letter-sized
scanning, plus faxing via your PC.
Using four DuraBrite pigmented ink
cartridges, it makes water-resistant
color copies and prints (single and
double-sided). The even fancier HP
PCS 2410 Photosmart (shown) offers
six-color output,
direct printing and
proofing from
media cards, and
color faxing. The
CX5200 streets at
about $150. The
HP 2410 is $300.
5
PRI M EPICKS
PRI NTERS
CANON i9100 PHOTO PRINTER
> WIDE-CARRIAGE SPEED DEMON
THE SKINNY: Terrific color output and blazing
speed, with 4x6s in about 37 sec, 8x10s in 1
min 13 sec, and borderless 13x19s in 6 min 7
sec. Image quality and resolution have improved
over the earlier S9000.
FEATURES TO LIKE:
User-replaceable printhead. Low-ink sensor
warns you when one of
the six individual ThinkTank ink cartridges is
running low. Borderless
prints right up to 13x19.
Very quiet operation.
VITAL
STATISTICS
4800x1200 dpi
>
3,072 nozzles
>
4-picoliter
>
droplets
Borderless prints
>
to 13x19
$500 street
>
>SIMILAR AND RECOMMENDED
Epson Stylus Photo 1280 ($380)
Tested Nov ember 2003
www.usa.canon.com
800-652-2666
EPSON STYLUS PHOTO 900
> A BARGAIN THAT ALSO PRINTS CDS AND D VDS
THE SKINNY: Letter-sized inkjet with high performance and a low price. Beautiful image quality thanks to six photo inks. Borderless 4x6s,
5x7s, and 8x10s. T emplate and softw are for
direct printing onto CDs and DVDs. Two large ink
cartridges (black and
color) offer extended
printing, but we’ d prefer six separate tanks.
FEATURES TO LIKE:
Accepts 4- and 8.3-in.
roll paper, prints banners up to 44 in. long.
Love that price!
VITAL
STATISTICS
5760x720 dpi
>
4-picoliter droplets
>
2 ink cartridges—
>
CcMmY plus
black
$185 street
>
>SIMILAR AND RECOMMENDED
Epson Stylus Photo 960 ($330)
Tested October 2003
www
EPSON STYLUS PHOTO 2200
> BIG BEAUTIFUL PRINTS THAT LAST AND LAST
THE SKINNY: Seven-color,junior version of
the Stylus Pro 7600 is much better than the
earlier Stylus Photo 2000P. Faster, wider color
gamut, neutral b&w output, banishes color
shifting under different
lighting. Great paper
handling. Lower price.
FEATURES TO LIKE:
Takes roll paper up to
13 in. wide. Auto paper
cutter and catch basket for easy batch printing. Optional Matte
Black ink gives better
matte and watercolor
prints.
VITAL
STATISTICS
>
2880x1440 dpi
>
4-picoliter droplets
>
7 individual
UltraChrome
pigmented ink
cartridges
>
Borderless prints
up to 13x44
>
$700 street
>SIMILAR AND RECOMMENDED
In a class of its own
Tested October 2002
www
.epson.com
800-463-7766
.epson.com
800-463-7766
HP P HOTOSMART
7960 PHOTO PRINTER
www.hp.com; 800-752-0900
> EIGHT COLORS AND B&W,TOO
THE SKINNY: A new level of dedicated photo
printing. Eight-ink system matches others in
color, and beats all in blackand-white with Photo Gray
ink. Print directly from built-in
media card slots, as well as
from compatible HP cameras.
Downside: slow.
FEATURES TO LIKE: 2.5-in.
swiveling LCD screen. Borderless prints up to 8.5x11.
Separate 25-sheet tray for
4x6s.
>SIMILAR AND RECOMMENDED
Canon i900D ($250)
VITAL
STATISTICS
4800x1200 dpi
>
4 cartridges hold
>
8 inks
Direct printing
>
from Photosmart
cameras and 6
media formats
$290 street
>
OLYMPUS P-440
www
.olympusamerica.com
> LIKE HAVING A MINILAB IN A BOX
THE SKINNY: Dye-sub prints
from this new machine (as
with the earlier,slower P-400)
rival lab prints for smoothness, feel, durability. Borderless 8x10s, 1.8-in. color LCD
monitor. Downside: uses only
Olympus paper.
FEATURES TO LIKE:Print
from built-in xD card slot,
other media via PCMCIA slot
and adapters. Glossy or
matte overcoat without
changing paper . Videoout lets you view and
edit on your TV.
>SIMILAR AND RECOMMENDED
Kodak Professional 8500 Digital Photo Printer
($900)
;800-622-6372
VITAL
STATISTICS
314 dpi
>
Continuous tone
>
16.7 million colors
>
3-pass CMY ink
>
ribbon plus clear
overcoat
Borderless 8x10s
>
$499 street
>
Loading...