DX Engineering DXE-UWA-END-KIT How Strong Are These Insulators?

How Strong are the
DX Engineering End Insulators?
Over 6 years ago, DX Engineering introduced the patented (US Patent No. D534,905) serpentine style end insulators (DXE-UWA-END-KIT) which are custom molded from high impact fiberglass impregnated nylon for tremendous breaking strength and UV protection. Since then, thousands of the DX Engineering End Insulators have been installed around the world.
The End Insulators were specifically designed to provide a strong wire gripping method by routing DXE Engineering Antenna Wire (DXE-ANTW series) through a series of slots in a serpentine manner. This allows easy, one-step length adjustment for tuning a dipole without having to terminate the wires.
DX Engineering Antenna Wire is a 14 gauge, 19 strand copper wire with a black ‘relaxed’ PVC insulation. This means the wire remains flexible, lays out flat and won’t coil up when tension is removed. This wire has been proven to be superior for dipole antennas and has consistently provided years of service without any problems.
Even when used in conjunction with heavier Baluns and long runs of antenna wire, the End Insulators continue to provide excellent holding capacity without wire slippage or creeping. DX Engineering uses the End Insulators in many of our products and assemblies, and sells them separately for your own projects.
Over the years, Amateur Radio Operators have used many different wire types to construct antennas. This prompted our Engineering Department to evaluate the DX Engineering End Insulators with several other types of commonly used wire.
We took samples of four types of wire and the DX Engineering End Insulators to an independent test laboratory and commissioned a series of pull tests. Tests using the four wire types showed varied results.
The four types of wire tested were:
DX Engineering Antenna Wire Typical ‘Big-Box’ store 14 gauge Insulated Wire Bare 14 gauge Copper-Clad Steel Wire 7-Strand Copper-Clad Steel Bare Wire Tinned Copper Flexible Weave Wire with no insulation
When the tests were completed, the results for the DX Engineering Antenna Wire proved that it was still the overall product of choice for use with the End Insulators.
When using the ‘Big-Box’ insulated wire, it was noted that the wire had a very thin clear plastic-like substance over the insulation and this would shed much like a snake skin, contributing to creep and slippage.
The single strand bare copper-clad steel wire was not easy to bend through the End Insulators and showed a tendency to coil up when relaxed (as expected). But once routed through the serpentine slots it did show very good resistance to slippage.
The 7-strand bare copper wire showed a tendency to coil up easily when not pulled taut (it had a “helical memory”) and it would creep and slip faster than compared to the previously tested types.
The flexible weave tinned copper wire was the last one tested. As expected, this type of wire was found to creep and slip through the serpentine slots most easily.
Following the test laboratory tests, DX Engineering personnel decided to investigate various ways to enhance the pull strength of the End Insulators. After making a few tests they came upon a very simple, solderless solution that dramatically increases the termination strength to the point of breaking the wire before it could creep or pull out.
The ultimate test of the insulator/wire junction does not require a strain gauge to measure. If the wire itself fails, the results cannot be more conclusive that the installation is the strongest possible.
They used the worst case type of wire - the Flexible Weave tinned copper wire (with no insulation). They routed the wire through the serpentine slots with an added loop back and through as shown in the picture below.
Using two trucks as anchors, they tied the ends securely to the rear of each while one slowly drove forward. The wire did not slip or creep. In fact it seemed to grip even tighter. The wire did stretch slightly and then broke. It broke in the area between the two trucks, not at the End Insulator. They repeated the test and the results were the same. The DX Engineering End Insulators held up 100% without failure.
Based on the tests, DX Engineering now suggests routing the wire through the End Insulators as shown. It will provide extra strength and prevent any creep or slippage of various types of antenna wire.
©DX Engineering 2013
P.O. Box 1491 - Akron, OH 44309-1491 USA
DXE End Insulators - Rev 0
Phone: 800-777-0703 - Tech Support and International: 330-562-3200 - Fax: 330-572-32679
E-mail: DXEngineering@DXEngineering.com
Loading...