5 Hardware Integration
Q: What is the reason for a limit of +2 dBi antenna gain when Europe allows transmits with 100 mW and US/Canada 1 W?
A: The limit on the antenna gain is not 2 dBi, and some customers have certified with antennas with higher gain. In supporting
a single product that can be certified world wide, the maximum radiated output power in band is +10 dBm/MHz. For mesh
networks, where one does not plan the direction for communication, omnidirectionality in an antenna is desirable. +2 dBi
antenna's are common in many different form factors, so +8 dBm output power is a natural output power to target given the
+10 dBm/MHz limit. While Europe allows 100 mW for module and only 10 mW for a
frequency hopping Direct Sequence
module, test data for a DSSS module can be taken as part of a data set used for certification in other
Spread Spectrum (DSSS)
geographies; whereas, data taken for a module is not consistent with other geographies. In addition, since
frequency hopping
the intention is to spread the energy across the band, channel hopping schemes are required to use at least 15 channels,
which makes blacklisting of select channels impossible according to the IEEE 802.15.4 channel assignments. We chose to
certify under spread spectrum rules to enable blacklisting, a required feature of the WirelessHART protocol. The draft version
of ETSI EN300 328 V1.8.1 places further restrictions on for module that will further reduce the
frequency hopping
attractiveness of certifying as a frequency hopper, while at the same time providing an opportunity for a a
Direct Sequence
module to operate above 10 mW. We are monitoring the progress of ETSI EN300 328 V1.8.1 with a
Spread Spectrum (DSSS)
mindset to try to allow for additional customer flexibility within the limits of the new regulations. Practically, there may be a
timing limitation for providing this based upon the relative approval of the specification relative the product's RPL date.
For North America, the rules for certification have changed, allowing a procedure that is not antenna specific and will allow for
higher gain antennas. The goal for the newer module products, LTP5900 and LTP5902 is to provide a certification that is both
independent of antenna type and higher gain.
Also note, Wireless Hart does specify that the nominal output power of a device must be 10 dBm, with our radios requiring a
+2 dBi antenna.
Q. If I'm using a modularly certified mote, do I have to get the whole product certified?
A. Modular certification allows a complete product to be certified as an unintentional radiator, as is required for any electronic
device that does not contain a radio. Radio specific testing is not required, and in fact disabling the radio for unintentional
radiator testings is preferred. If a product complies with Part 15, has the appropriate labeling, a compliant antenna, and has
performed the unintentional radiator scans, the product is certified.
Q. Are there other certifications (radio or otherwise) needed?
A. Per geographies that support modular certification, no additional radio certifications required. Depending on the complete
target's application other certifications may be required for such requirements as safety, intrinsic safety, application specific
certifications that can include operation under humidity, vibration, temperature cycling, salt fog, shock, etc.; however, those
tests are not specific to a product including a radio or not.